Next story in Health. The United States has a history of not always protecting the rights of the most vulnerable. As these children grow larger, it takes more strength to move them and provide basic bodily care, raising the risk of pressure sores from immobility. In Canadaethicist Arthur Schafer 's nationwide opinion piece  defending the operation as justifiable considering Ashley's comfort engendered criticism from disability rights activists such as Dave Hingsburger  of the York Central Hospital and Keenan Wellar from the LiveWorkPlay self-advocacy organization. Schwartman B. The parents presented a letter from their lawyer arguing that, as a legal matter and according to case law in Washington, a court order was not necessary. Looking back on the debate within the Seattle Children's Hospital ethics committee, the doctors admit that there was an instinctive, emotional ingredient in the decision to proceed with hormone treatments and surgery. Nonetheless, she is alert and responsive to her environment, particularly enjoying the music of Andrea Bocelli. Retrieved
Is the “Ashley Treatment” ethical Institute of Clinical Bioethics
The Ashley Treatment refers to a controversial set of medical procedures undergone by an Her parents have nicknamed Ashley "Pillow Angel", because she always remains where she is placed, which is usually on a pillow. In when The Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund (DREDF) declared, " we hold as. Nancy Gibbs talks with disability rights advocates, who see a Her parents have approved growth-stunting medical treatment that will ensure.
Video: Pillow angel parents rights Parent Video: School Refusal Behavior
What kind of doctors would agree to intentionally shorten and sterilize a disabled six-year-old girl to make it easier for her parents to take care of her?
Dr. Daniel Gunther and Dr. Douglas Diekema, who first revealed the details of "The Ashley Case" in the Archives of Pediatric.
Finally, justice recognizes that each person should be treated fairly and equitably, and be given his or her due.
Wikinews has related news: Ethical debate surrounds surgery to stunt disabled girl's growth. Not having breasts would also make the harness straps that hold her upright more comfortable.
Medical professionals have an ethical obligation to use available resources fairly and to distribute them fairly and equitably. If the Ashley Treatment becomes widely accepted, could this lead to the use of more controversial procedures that might reduce the size or reproductive capacity of other vulnerable people?
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med.
Pillow Angel Ethics TIME
Is this level of medical. The Ashley treatment made her far more likely to be comfortable.
human right is not to be blocked from receiving a treatment that her parents.
Through high-dose estrogen treatment over the past two years, her growth plates were closed and her prospective height reduced by about 13 inches, to 4'5". The risks of high-dose estrogen therapy include blood clots, deep vein thrombosis and it affects lipid metabolism. Medical correspondent Elizabeth Cohen and senior producer Jennifer Pifer contributed to this report.
Ethical Analysis The issue of the Ashley Treatment has raised serious interdisciplinary concerns. The Seattle Post Intelligencer [serial on the Internet].
Story Highlights; Parents of "pillow angel" stand by their decision to As parents we have a sacred duty to do what we believe is right for our. Ashley, called the “pillow angel” by her parents, suffers from a Those advocating for the rights of the disabled see this treatment as potentially.
The Groningen protocol.
Opponents argue that the treatment and surgery are nonbeneficial because Ashley is not suffering, the treatment is untested and has potential adverse effects, and the surgery is unnecessary because there are viable options.
The Ashley treatment 'Her life is as good as we can possibly make it' Society The Guardian
Daniel Gunther, "Ashley has no concept of these things. The Daily Telegraph. This procedure may be preventative but the benefits seem minimal.
Pillow angel parents rights
|What criteria do we use for determining if the surgery is beneficial?
Video: Pillow angel parents rights Altering the Disabled: The "Pillow Angel" Controversy - Originally broadcast Feb. 17, 2008
Would they agree to amputate a child's legs to keep her lighter and more portable? Contact us. Learn more. The United States has a history of not always protecting the rights of the most vulnerable.
Next story in Health.